FYI: Science Policy News
FYI
/
Newsletter
WEEK Of AUGUST 5, 2024
What’s Ahead

Editor’s note: The next edition of FYI This Week will be published in September.

russell-rotunda.jpg

An empty rotunda in a congressional office building.

Architect of the Capitol

Election Looms Over Congressional Calendar

Congress is in recess until September as lawmakers ramp up their campaigning ahead of the November election. Few bills are expected to cross the finish line until after the election, and some may be abandoned until 2025 if either party senses they will have greater advantage under the next Congress or presidential administration.

This dynamic has already contributed to the demise of a bipartisan tax policy bill that included provisions to strengthen the R&D tax credit. Although the House passed the bill by a wide margin in January, Senate Republicans blocked the bill last week, with some pointing out they will have more leverage over tax policy if they prevail in the election.

Congress could also punt negotiations on federal agency budgets into the new year, though there will be less incentive to do so if control of the White House and Congress remains split between the parties. In any event, neither party is likely to win a filibuster-proof majority in the Senate, meaning the final spending legislation will need some amount of bipartisan support. Senate appropriators have taken a bipartisan approach to developing their spending legislation for fiscal year 2025, which means their proposals are likely closer to the ultimate outcome than the House’s partisan bills.

Senate appropriators advanced more of their spending proposals last week, including a bill that would increase the DOE Office of Science budget by 4.4% to $8.6 billion , slightly exceeding the Biden administration’s budget request. They also proposed to increase the National Institutes of Health budget by 3.6% to $50.3 billion, though much of the increase relies on “emergency” funding that exceeds the statutory caps on federal spending. House Republicans are likely to insist that Congress adhere to the caps, meaning it will be more difficult to secure spending increases in the final legislation.

National Quantum Initiative Advisors Meet Amid Reauthorization Push

The National Quantum Initiative Advisory Committee will meet on Tuesday to consider approving recommendations concerning quantum networking. The meeting comes as efforts to update the National Quantum Initiative have stalled. The NQI Act of 2018 launched a ten-year interagency effort but the authorization of many of its components expired in 2023 at the halfway mark. Though Congress has continued to fund these components despite the lapse, quantum advocates are seeking to renew Congress’ endorsement of the initiative and expand it into new areas. For instance, the Department of Energy Quantum Leadership Act introduced by Sens. Dick Durbin (D-IL) and Steve Daines (R-MT) last week would recommend Congress exceed the spending targets for DOE in the original NQI legislation.

What’s on Your Mind as the Election Approaches?

With the November presidential election around the corner, FYI is interested in hearing what science policy issues are on your mind. Email us at fyi@aip.org with your thoughts. We will not publish anything you send without your consent.

Also On Our Radar

  • The National Academies will release a report assessing the state of high-magnetic-field science in the U.S. on Aug. 13 and a report on expanding defense research at minority-serving institutions on Aug. 20.
  • The National Science Foundation has just awarded $51 million to five projects that will assess the effectiveness of U.S. R&D efforts and develop tools to inform future spending decisions. The awards are the first made by NSF’s Assessing and Predicting Technology Outcomes program.
  • The House Science Committee is continuing to press the professional society Optica regarding its interactions with Chinese telecommunications company Huawei. (Optica is an AIP Member Society.)
  • The Nancy Grace Roman Telescope remains on track to launch by May 2027 within the $4.3 billion budget set by the mission’s 2021 replan, says a new audit from NASA’s Office of Inspector General. The audit did however find there are still “signficant risks” to NASA’s plan for transmitting data from the telescope to Earth.
The agency awarded $18 million to six projects that will pursue unconventional hypotheses and methodology.

The new policy will shape research security standards for federally funded institutions as scientists navigate an increasingly fraught geopolitical environment.

Chair Darío Gil discussed the need for a more coordinated plan for scientific progress in a time of “radical” change for global R&D.

Upcoming Events

All events are Eastern Time, unless otherwise noted. Listings do not imply endorsement. Events beyond this week are listed on our website.

Monday, August 5

AMS: 2024 Summer Community Meeting (continues Tuesday)

Tuesday, August 6

National Academies: A science strategy for the human exploration of Mars: Panel on biological and physical sciences and human factors, meeting one (continues through Thursday)

National Academies: Barriers and opportunities for facilitating team science workshop (continues Wednesday)

BIS: Sensors and Instrumentation Technical Advisory Committee meeting
1:00 - 2:30 pm

DOE: National Quantum Initiative Advisory Committee meeting
1:00 - 3:00 pm

Wednesday, August 7

NDIA: Emerging Technologies for Defense Conference (continues through Friday)

NIST: Advisory Committee on Earthquake Hazards Reduction meeting (continues Thursday)

National Academies: 2025 Mirzayan S&T Policy Fellowship informational webinar
2:00 - 3:00 pm

Thursday, August 8

AAAS: So many kinds of AI! Generative, predictive and more - what do they all mean?
2:00 - 3:00 pm

EPA: National Environmental Justice Advisory Council meeting
1:00 - 6:30 pm

National Academies: Quadrennial review of the National Nanotechnology Initiative meeting
3:00 - 4:00 pm

Monday, August 12

National Academies: Future STEM workforce skills, gaps, and staffing demand reflecting new student dynamics
2:00 - 3:30 pm

Tuesday, August 13

DOD: Board on Coastal Engineering Research meeting (continues Wednesday)

National Academies: Assessing and navigating biosecurity concerns and benefits of AI use in the life sciences meeting (continues Wednesday)

NNSA: Advisory Committee for Nuclear Security meeting (closed)
9:00 am - 5:00 pm

National Academies: The current status and future direction of high-magnetic-field science in the US, report release webinar
1:00 - 2:00 pm

Wednesday, August 14

DNFSB: Public hearing on benchmarking best practices in management of aging safety infrastructure
9:00 am - 3:30 pm

Monday, August 19

National Academies: Research agenda for reducing the climate impact of aviation-induced cloudiness and persistent contrails from commercial aviation, meeting four (continues through Wednesday)

Tuesday, August 20

National Academies: A plan to expand defense research at minority-serving institutions, report release webinar
11:00 am - 12:30 pm

AAAS: Life after the S&T Policy Fellowship: Career exploration
1:00 - 2:00 pm

Wednesday, August 21

National Academies: Workshop on scientific, industry, innovation, and governance landscape for biotechnology R&D in the US and India (continues Thursday)

Thursday, August 22

National Academies: Quadrennial review of the National Nanotechnology Initiative meeting
3:00 - 4:00 pm

Friday, August 23

USGS: Advisory Council for Climate Adaptation Science meeting
10:00 am - 5:00 pm

Monday, August 26

DOD: Defense Science Board meeting (closed) (continues through Friday)

National Academies: A science strategy for the human exploration of Mars (continues through Wednesday)

Wednesday, August 28

National Academies: Biotechnology cooperation for the US-India Initiative on Critical and Emerging Technology (iCET): Workshop one
10:00 am - 12:30 pm

DOE: Industrial Technology Innovation Advisory Committee
2:00 - 4:00 pm

Thursday, August 29

FCC: Technological Advisory Council meeting
10:00 am - 12:30 pm

NRC: Advisory Committee on the Medical Uses of Isotopes meeting
2:00 - 4:00 pm

NASA: Interagency Nuclear Safety Review Board meeting
3:00 - 4:00 pm

National Academies: Quadrennial review of the National Nanotechnology Initiative meeting
3:00 - 4:00 pm

Friday, August 30

National Academies: Biotechnology cooperation for the US-India Initiative on Critical and Emerging Technology (iCET): Workshop two
10:00 am - 12:30 pm

Monday, September 2

Labor Day.

Know of an upcoming science policy event either inside or outside the Beltway? Email us at fyi@aip.org.

Opportunities

Job Openings

Sky & Telescope: Editor in chief (ongoing)
Optica: Senior editor and content director for Optics and Photonics News (ongoing)
AAAS: Director, Sciline (ongoing)
◆CCST: Deputy director, California Council on Science and Technology (ongoing)
NOAA: Supervisory foreign affairs specialist (Aug. 9)
◆NSF: Research security program director (Aug. 12)
◆NSF: Head of Geosciences Directorate (Aug. 14)
NSF: Director, Astronomical Sciences Division (Aug. 14)
DOE: Industrial Decarbonization Office Fellowship (Aug. 15)
◆GAO: Physical scientist, Science, Technology Assessment, and Analytics group (Aug. 16)
◆AIP: Science policy intern (Aug. 18)
◆DOE: Director, Enabling Science and Partnerships Division, Office of Fusion Energy Sciences (extended to Aug. 20)
Horizon Institute: Horizon Fellowship (Aug. 30)
National Academies: 2025 Mirzayan S&T Policy Graduate Fellowship (Sept. 9)

Solicitations

Issues in S&T: Survey on who does S&T policy (ongoing)
USGS: Call for nominations for the National Geospatial Advisory Committee (Aug. 7)
DOE: RFI on equity action plan update (Aug. 9)
NSF: RFI on National Network for Microelectronics Education Program (Aug. 14)
House: RFC on NIH reform (Aug. 16)
NIH: RFI on draft public access policy (Aug. 19)
DOE: RFC on conflict of interest and conflict of commitment policy requirements (Aug. 19
NTIA: RFC on the advancement of 6G telecommunications technology (Aug. 21)
DOD: RFI on financing support for covered technology categories (Oct. 22)
NIH: RFI on re-envisioning US postdoctoral research training and career progression (Oct. 23)

Around the Web

News and views currently in circulation. Links do not imply endorsement.

White House

White House: Second US-Singapore critical and emerging technology dialogue
White House: OSTP climate and environment leaders emphasize key role of nature in US federal policy
Science: Mainstreaming nature in US federal policy (perspective by Heather Tallis, et al.)
SpaceNews: Space industry considers implications of Harris as presidential candidate
Stat: With Biden’s departure in sight, advocates seek to preserve gains of Cancer Moonshot

Congress

Fedscoop: Eyebrow-raising AI amendment passes Senate Commerce committee
House Science Committee: Committee leaders introduce AI workforce bill
Sen. Marco Rubio (R-FL): Republicans introduce bill barring federal government from using adversarial AI
House CCP Committee: Bipartisan legislation introduced to drive American leadership in semiconductor R&D
Science: Senate bill would give NIH $2 billion raise and crack down on harassers
E&E News: How the landmark clmate law hobbled Joe Manchin

Science, Society, and the Economy

National Academies: Impacts of NSF engineering research support on society (report)
Science and Public Policy: Operation Warp Speed: Harbinger of American industrial innovation policies (paper by William Bonvillian)
MIT Technology Review: How the US and its allies can rebuild economic security (perspective by Edlyn Levine and Fiona Murray)
IEEE Spectrum: The saga of AD-X2, the battery additive that roiled the NBS
Issues in Science and Technology: Supporting scientific citizens (perspective by Lisa Margonelli)
New York Times: Can the Higgs Boson become a Broadway star?
Nature: Maxine Singer obituary: biologist who shaped genetic engineering and fought discrimination

Education and Workforce

Physics Today: Survey asks majors: Why physics?
Research Professional: UK universities accused of ‘naive’ approach to economic espionage
Nature: Predatory conferences are on the rise. Here are five ways to tackle them (editorial)
Nature: How to spot a predatory conference, and what science needs to do about them: a guide
Scientific American: Jess Wade is on a crusade to correct Wikipedia’s gender imbalance
Chemical & Engineering News: Chemists smash period stigma with a podcast
Nature: Quantum computing aims for diversity, one qubit at a time
Stat: Diversity statements should not be required for federal STEMM grant funding (perspective by Jeffrey Flier)
Nature: US postdoc support from NIH could be capped at five years — sparking criticism
Research Policy: New evidence on international postdocs in the US: Less pay, different experiences (paper by Shulamit Kahn and Megan MacGarvie)

Research Management

MIT Technology Review: The US physics community is not done working on trust (perspective by Frances Houle, et al.)
Science: Authors are increasingly paying to publish their papers open access. But is it fair or sustainable?
Nature: Stop just paying lip service on publication integrity (perspective by Andrew Grey, et al.)
Nature: ‘Publish or Perish’ is now a card game — not just an academic’s life
Science|Business: How will the new US research security center work? (interview with Mark Haselkron)
Chronicle of Higher Education: Two major academic publishers signed deals with AI companies. Some professors are outraged
Nature: AI is complicating plagiarism. How should scientists respond?
Retraction Watch: Science and the significant trend towards spin and fairytales (perspective by Simon Gandevia)

Labs and Facilities

The Infrastructure Show: Big infrastructure for big science - The Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment (audio)
Battelle: Juan Alvarez named executive vice president of Battelle
NOIRLab: Rubin Observatory’s secondary mirror installed
Fusion Industry Association: FIA urges greater information sharing in letter to ITER director-general
USGS: Hawaiian Volcano Observatory bids farewell to its Uēkahuna location
USGS: New report ranks USGS assets high among Earth observations systems surveyed
Science: Bad agar is killing lab yeast around the world. Where is it coming from?

Computing and Communications

NIST: Secure software development practices for generative AI and dual-use foundation models (report)
FedScoop: Commerce report recommends government monitor open AI foundation model risks
CSET: The finalized EU Artificial Intelligence Act: Implications and insights
Wired: To lead in AI, the US needs a silicon revolution (interview with Laurie Locascio)
AP: Chipmaker Intel to cut 15,000 jobs as tries to revive its business and compete with rivals
IEEE Spectrum: How India is starting a chip industry from scratch
Breaking Defense: SASC orders Pentagon transparency in spectrum dispute with Ligado

Space

AP: Canada completes negotiations to use US space launch technology, expertise, and data
SpaceNews: Companies describe studies to revise Mars Sample Return
New York Times: Peter Theisinger, 78, dies; led Mars rover missions for NAS
Scientific American: NASA losing VIPER Rover defangs the science from planned moon landings (perspective by Thomas Zurbuchen and Nadia Drake)
SpaceNews: NASA to soon resume awards of lunar lander missions
GAO: Artemis programs: NASA should document and communicate plans to address Gateway’s mass risk (report)
Ars Technica: NASA’s Lunar Gateway has a big visiting vehicles problem
SpaceNews: Chinese scientists outline major cislunar space infrastructure project
Scientific American: NASA retires asteroid-hunting telescope
Ars Technica: With a landmark launch, the Pentagon is finally free of Russian rocket engines

Weather, Climate, and Environment

Wall Street Journal: AI is learning to predict the weather
Wired: The new gods of weather can make rain on demand — or so they want you to believe
New York Times: This scientist has a risky plan to cool Earth (interview with David Keith)
Chemical & Engineering News: US methane emissions dwarf EPA’s data
E&E News: EPA’s $27B challenge: Find private financing for climate projects
New York Times: Olympic surfing comes to a ‘poisoned’ paradise
Physics World: From new physics to sustainability, particle physics looks to the future (perspective by Katherine Skipper)

Energy

Physics Today: Harnessing energy from laser fusion
Fusion Industry Association: FIA releases letter to US Treasury on tax credit inclusion of fusion
American Nuclear Society: UK, Japan step up progress toward fusion power demonstrations
GAO: Nuclear waste cleanup: More effective oversight is needed to help ensure better project outcomes (report)
Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists: Why US nuclear waste policy got stalled. And what to do about it (perspective by By Victor Gilinsky)
American Nuclear Society: DOE asks for input on spent fuel package safety demonstration
Physics World: Why NASA thinks you should forget about space-based solar power (perspective by James McKenzie)

Defense

DNI: National Counterintelligence Strategy 2024 (report)
ChinaTalk: The CHIPS Act and national security (interview with Ben Schwartz)
Breaking Defense: DOD ‘exploring’ options for nuclear buildup as part of strategic review
Breaking Defense: US needs more nuclear subs, mobile ICBMs and tactical nukes: Heritage report
DOD: Pentagon official: Alliances are key to US nuclear deterrence advantage
DOE: Amended record of decision for the continued operation of the Nevada National Security Site and off-site locations in Nevada
Foreign Affairs: Why America stands to lose if it resumes nuclear testing (perspective by Jeffrey Lewis)
Breaking Defense: Pentagon R&D chief defends RDER experimentation initiative after Senate broadside
Inside Defense: DARPA under fire from Senate appropriators over alleged financial misrepresentation

Biomedical

Science: NIH loses latest round of free speech lawsuit filed by animal rights activists
Nature: The pathogens that could spark the next pandemic
Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists: How international labs could prevent leaks — and produce cutting-edge pathogen research (perspective by Sandra Lopez-Verges)
Stat: The coronavirus lab leak hypothesis is damaging science (perspective by John Moore)
Federal Demonstration Partnership: Strategies for assessing efforts in preparing NIH institutional training grants

International Affairs

Nature: How a space physicist is shaking up China’s research funding
ChinaTalk: Tech policy at China’s Third Plenum
Space Review: Is the US doing enough to engage with China on space policy? (perspective by Mariam Kvaratskhelia)
Issues in Science and Technology: South Korea’s bold shift toward international S&T collaboration requires transforming the weaknesses of the current system into future strengths (perspective by Kyung Ryul Park)
Science|Business: Repression grows in Russian universities
Politico: Moscow’s spies were stealing US tech — until the FBI started a sabotage campaign
Nature: I’m a Palestinian scientist building a more inclusive future (interview with Rana Dajani)
Science|Business: Why Europe must invest in research infrastructures now (perspective by Thomas Feurer)
Research Professional: Researchers ‘need European data protection guidelines’

More from FYI
FYI
/
Article
Hostility to China, equity initiatives, and the federal bureaucracy will be key forces in the new administration.
FYI
/
Article
The principles aim to build public trust in climate intervention experiments, as several have been blocked by local opposition.
FYI
/
Article
Signs that the cables holding up the 900-ton receiver were slipping from their sockets should have been a red flag.
FYI
/
Article
The rule is the latest in a string of restrictions targeting strategic technologies.

Sign up for FYI This Week, our weekly digest of science policy news.

By signing up you agree to allow AIP to send you email newsletters. You further agree to our privacy policy and terms of service.