FYI: Science Policy News
The Week of March 18, 2019

What’s Ahead

Russell Vought FY2020 Testimony

Acting White House Budget Director Russell Vought testifying on the president’s budget request for fiscal year 2020.

(Image credit - Senate Budget Committee)

Budget Rollout Continues

The Trump administration is continuing its rollout of the fiscal year 2020 budget request this week. The White House Office of Management and Budget published supplementary material on Monday, including a chapter on R&D spending across the government. Individual agencies are also expected to issue additional budget documentation in the coming days, and some details have already emerged. The Department of Energy posted a “budget in brief” document late last week that includes topline figures for the main programs within the DOE Office of Science and other offices across the agency. See FYI’s Federal Science Budget Tracker for details. In testimony last week, Acting White House Budget Director Russell Vought defended the administration’s proposed cuts across nondefense programs as prudent in a time of ballooning deficits and noted that some are simply rollbacks of recent increases.

Space Scientists Convene for Goddard Symposium

The American Astronautical Society’s annual Robert H. Goddard Memorial Symposium is taking place Tuesday through Thursday in Silver Spring, Maryland. Deputy NASA Administrator James Morhard and National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Deputy Administrator Tim Gallaudet will deliver keynote addresses to open the conference. Panels will present on the future of the fields represented by NASA’s four space science divisions: Earth science, planetary science, astrophysics, and heliophysics. Sessions on NASA’s planned lunar architecture and the intertwining of science with human exploration will address the agency’s efforts to build a new paradigm for science missions on and around the Moon and eventually beyond.

Directed Energy Summit to Spotlight Progress on Future Weapons

Top defense industry and military officials are gathering in Washington, D.C., this week for the fifth annual Directed Energy Summit . Directed energy technologies include laser weapons as well as weapons based on microwave and particle beams. Among the speakers are Under Secretary of Defense for Research and Engineering Mike Griffin, a proponent of developing directed energy technologies for missile defense applications, Thomas Karr, whom Griffin picked last June to lead a new office dedicated to directed energy, and Keith Englander, director for engineering at the Missile Defense Agency. The administration’s recently released Missile Defense Review emphasizes the potential of directed energy, and at a budget briefing last week, the Missile Defense Agency’s acting director for operations indicated it is planning to scale up laser power levels and pursue a “new effort” to develop neutral particle beam technology.

‘Science During Crisis’ Report Set for Release

The American Academy of Arts and Sciences is releasing a report on Tuesday that examines how science could be better leveraged during responses to natural disasters. Titled “Science During Crisis,” the report discusses the integration of scientists into crisis response teams and emerging best practices. Former National Science Foundation Director Rita Colwell, a co-author of the report, will speak at the event.

In Case You Missed It


From left, Sen. Tammy Duckworth (D-IL), Sen. Dick Durbin (D-IL), Rep. Sean Casten (D-IL), Rep. Robin Kelly (D-IL), Rep. Bill Foster (D-IL), Fermilab Director Nigel Lockyer, Rep. Lauren Underwood (D-IL), Illinois Governor J. B. Pritzker (D), Department of Energy Under Secretary for Science Paul Dabbar, PIP-II Project Director Lia Merminga, DOE Associate Director for High Energy Physics Jim Siegrist, University of Chicago President Robert Zimmer, and Consul General of India Neeta Bhushan ceremonially break ground on Fermilab’s PIP-II project. Off camera to the right are British Consul General John Saville, Consul General of Italy Giuseppe Finocchiaro, Consul General of France Guillaume Lacroix, DOE Fermi Site Office Manager Mike Weis, DOE PIP-II Federal Project Director Adam Bihary, and Consul General of Poland Piotr Janicki.

(Image credit – Office of Sen. Dick Durbin)

Fermilab Breaks Ground on PIP-II Accelerator

At a ceremony on March 15, Fermilab broke ground on the Proton Improvement Plan II (PIP-II) project, a major upgrade to the Fermilab Accelerator Complex. PIP-II is integral to the lab’s plans for the LBNF/DUNE experiment, which will send neutrinos through the Earth to a detector at the Sanford Underground Research Facility in South Dakota. The objective is to gain a better understanding of the elusive particles’ behavior, which could lead to new insights into the fundamental physics of the universe. The neutrino beam is scheduled to begin operating in 2026. The Department of Energy’s approved cost range for PIP-II’s construction is $653 million to $928 million, and it is the first U.S.-based accelerator project to also receive significant contributions from international partners. The ceremony was attended by representatives of partner nations, both of Illinois’ senators, and four of the state’s congressional representatives, including Rep. Bill Foster (D-IL), who was an accelerator designer at the lab before his election to the House.

FCC Proceeds with Spectrum Auction Despite Science Concerns

Last week the Federal Communications Commission moved forward with an auction to open a portion of the electromagnetic spectrum to providers of next-generation telecommunications technology, dismissing concerns that new use of the 24 to 25 gigahertz band could interfere with satellites that collect data for weather research and observations. NASA and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration sent a letter to the FCC on Feb. 28 warning that such interference would disrupt the transmission of “critical Earth science data.” Leaders of the House Science Committee and three appropriations subcommittees also sent letters to the FCC calling on the body to delay the auction and support an interagency review of potential interferences.

Scientific Integrity Act Reintroduced

Last week Rep. Paul Tonko (D-NY) and Sen. Brian Schatz (D-HI) reintroduced the Scientific Integrity Act . The bill was originally introduced early in the last Congress by Tonko and former Sen. Bill Nelson (D-FL) in view of their concerns the Trump administration was seeking to politically interfere with the work of scientists employed at federal agencies. In a joint statement with Schatz, Tonko asserted such concerns have been warranted, saying, “President Trump’s multi-agency assault on environmental standards has hinged on efforts to distort, bury, and even rewrite credible public scientific findings, including his absurd denial of the growing climate crisis and efforts to cover up evidence that the American people are being exposed to dangerous toxins.” Under the Obama administration, more than 20 federal agencies developed scientific integrity policies, albeit with varying levels of detail. Tonko’s and Schatz’s legislation would require and standardize such policies by statute and subject them to a review.

NASA Open to Commercial Alternatives for Planned SLS Launches

At a Senate hearing last week, NASA Administrator Jim Bridenstine testified he is open to using commercial rockets to meet a June 2020 milestone for launching a new crew vehicle into lunar space. Current plans call for the Space Launch System (SLS) rocket that NASA is developing to serve that purpose, but Bridenstine acknowledged SLS is “struggling to meet its schedule.” NASA has previously justified SLS as the only choice for launching heavy payloads, including human exploration crews, beyond low Earth orbit. Congress has also stipulated the agency should use it to launch two planned missions to Jupiter’s moon Europa. In its recent budget requests, though, NASA has proposed using commercial launch vehicles for the Europa mission, arguing it would be more economical and reserve SLS launches for advancing NASA’s lunar exploration plans.

NASA’s Process for Cancelling Europa Instrument Questioned

The Outer Planets Assessment Group (OPAG), an independent panel that advises NASA, released a letter on March 13 questioning the agency’s recent decision to cancel a magnetometer the Jet Propulsion Laboratory was developing for the Europa Clipper mission. NASA explained that the instrument’s cost growth breached thresholds that “trigger” a review by the agency of its inclusion on the spacecraft. OPAG states that the cancellation came as a surprise to the science community, that the process NASA used “appears to be new,” and that there is a “perception of unfairness” in how the decision was made. Accordingly, the group asks NASA to explain the process in further detail and have it formally examined by the National Academies Committee for Astrobiology and Planetary Science.

Science Committee Delves into Space Traffic Management

Much of the House Science Committee’s first hearing of the new Congress on space policy focused on the challenges posed by orbital debris. Space Subcommittee Chair Kendra Horn (D-OK) highlighted testimony indicating the U.S. lacks the capability to track the over 600,000 pieces of orbital debris smaller than 10 centimeters that are believed to exist. Frank Rose, a security fellow at the Brookings Institution, stressed that human and robotic missions are threatened in a space environment that is becoming “increasingly congested, competitive, and contested.” Horn also asked about the planned transfer of certain space traffic management responsibilities from the Department of Defense to a civilian agency, expressing concern about a potential loss of capabilities. Rose replied that he supports the transfer but added “my kind of plea to the committee is use your oversight powers to make sure we’re doing it the right way because we can’t afford to get this wrong.”

Pentagon Stands Up Space Development Agency

Acting Defense Secretary Patrick Shanahan signed a memorandum on March 12 officially establishing a Space Development Agency under the Department of Defense. The memo states the agency will “define and monitor the department’s future threat-driven space architecture and will accelerate the development and fielding of new military space capabilities necessary to ensure our technological and military advantage in space for national defense.” In its fiscal year 2020 budget request, the Trump administration has asked for $150 million for the agency. Its first director is Fred Kennedy, who previously directed the Tactical Technology Office in the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency. Air Force Secretary Heather Wilson, who recently announced plans to resign, opposed creating a Space Development Agency, arguing it would duplicate existing Air Force activities. However, the Defense Department states it will perform a complementary, department-wide function and plans to transition it into the proposed Space Force. Mike Griffin, the under secretary of defense for research and engineering, told reporters , “We don’t have the time, the money, the brainpower, or the energy to do duplicative things.”

Landmark Public Lands Bill Now Law

On March 12, President Trump signed legislation containing over 100 bills related to public lands and natural resources. The law includes a handful of provisions related to natural hazards that gained support during the previous Congress. In a statement on the signing, Sen. Maria Cantwell (D-WA), a primary co-sponsor of the legislation, highlighted provisions aiming to improve volcano monitoring and wildfire fighting technology. Initially called the Natural Resources Management Act, the bill was renamed the John D. Dingell, Jr. Conservation, Management, and Recreation Act in honor of the long-serving congressman, who died last month.

Events This Week

Monday, March 18

AUECO: “Conference on the Impact of Export Controls on Higher Education and Scientific Institutions” (continues through Thursday) San Diego, CA LPI: Lunar and Planetary Science Conference (continues through Friday) Woodlands, TX ASU CSPO: “Project Confluence: Engineering and Science for Environmental, Climate, and Energy Justice” 8:30 - 10:30 am, ASU Washington Center (1800 I St. NW, DC) National Academies: “Understanding Success and Failure of Students in Developmental Mathematics” (continues Tuesday) 9:00 am - 4:30 pm, Mon; 9:00 am - 4:00 pm, Tue National Academy of Sciences (2101 Constitution Ave. NW, DC) Webcast available NSF: Environmental Research and Education Advisory Committee teleconference 11:00 am - 1:00 pm

Tuesday, March 19

American Astronautical Society: Goddard Symposium (continues through Thursday) Silver Spring, MD DOE: Hydrogen and Fuel Cell Technical Advisory Committee meeting 8:00 am - 6:30 pm, NREL DC Office (901 D St. SW, DC) National Academies: “Domestic Manufacturing Capabilities for Critical DOD Applications: Emerging Needs in Quantum-Enabled Systems” (continues Wednesday) 8:30 am - 5:00 pm, Tue; 8:30 am - 2:30 pm, Wed National Academy of Sciences (2101 Constitution Ave. NW, DC) American Academy of Arts and Sciences: “Science During Crisis: The Release of a New Report and Call to Action” 9:00 am, National Press Club (529 14th St. NW, DC) STEM Education Coalition: “STEM Education 101: Major Policy Issues for the 116th Congress,” congressional briefing 2:00 - 3:00 pm, 2325 Rayburn House Office Building

Wednesday, March 20

UMD: “Workshop on Opportunities, Challenges, and Best Practices for Basic Plasma Science User Facilities” (continues Thursday) College Park, MD Booz Allen Hamilton: Directed Energy Summit (continues Thursday) Reagan International Trade Center (1300 Pennsylvania Ave. NW, DC) DOD: Defense Science Board meeting (continues Thursday) Closed to the public C2ES: Climate Leadership Conference (continues through Friday) Baltimore, MD DOD: Board on Coastal Engineering Research meeting (continues Thursday) Gulfport, MS CSIS: “Strategic National Security Space: FY 2020 Budget and Policy Forum” 8:30 - 11:45 am, CSIS headquarters (1616 Rhode Island Ave. NW, DC) Webcast available Wilson Center: “Implementing the U.S. Global Water Strategy: A First-Year Review” 9:00 am - 12:30 pm, Wilson Center (1300 Pennsylvania Ave. NW, DC) Webcast available NASA: Aeronautics Advisory Committee meeting 10:00 am - 4:00 pm, NASA headquarters (300 E St. SW, DC) Webcast available Stimson: “The Future of Nuclear Arms Control” 12:30 - 2:00 pm, Stimson Center (1211 Connecticut Ave. NW, DC) Webcast available

Thursday, March 21

DNFSB: Defense Nuclear Facilities Safety Board meeting 9:00 am - 12:00 pm, DNFSB headquarters (625 Indiana Ave. NW, DC) DOD: Defense Innovation Board meeting 9:30 am - 12:20 pm, National Defense University (260 5th Ave. SW, DC) National Academies: “STEM Workforce Diversity: Where Do We Go From Here?” 2:00 - 4:00 pm, National Academy of Sciences (2101 Constitution Ave. NW, DC) National Academies: “Representing the Invisible: Exploring Inclusivity in the Arts and Sciences” 6:30 - 9:00 pm, Keck Center (500 5th St. NW, DC) Webcast available

Friday, March 22

National Academies: “The Future of Water” 8:30 - 10:30 am, Keck Center (500 5th St. NW, DC)

Monday, March 25

DOE: “The Promise and Potential of Micro-Reactors” 11:00 am - 12:00 pm, Webinar Atlantic Council: “Climate Change and National Security: Protecting Integrity of Threat Assessments” 2:00 - 3:30 pm, Atlantic Council headquarters (1030 15th St. NW, DC)


Appropriations Panels Accepting Input on FY20 Budget

Several House Appropriations subcommittees are accepting testimony from the public to inform their development of spending legislation for fiscal year 2020. The Commerce, Justice, Science Subcommittee is accepting submissions through April 4 and the Energy-Water Development Subcommittee is accepting submissions through April 12. Details for each subcommittee are available here .

STPI Seeking Science Policy Analyst

The Science and Technology Policy Institute is seeking applicants for a research analyst position. The institute supports the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy and other federal science agencies to develop and evaluate national policies and initiatives. Applicants must have a doctorate in a science or engineering field and at least five years of subsequent research or policy experience. Submissions are due March 29.

AAAS Hiring for Several Programs

The American Association for the Advancement of Science is hiring an associate program director for the Dialogue on Science, Ethics, and Religion program, a program associate in the Center for Public Engagement with Science and Technology, and a program associate to support the National Science Foundation S-STEM principal investigator community. Applications are due April 13.

Know of an upcoming science policy opportunity? Email us at of an upcoming science policy event? Email us at

Around the Web

News and views currently in circulation. Links do not imply endorsement.

Budget Request

White House


Political Engagement

Science, Society, and the Economy

Education and Workforce

Research Management

Labs and Facilities


Quantum Science and Technology


Weather, Climate, and Environment



International Affairs

More from FYI
The High Energy Physics Advisory Panel has proposed ways the U.S. can become a more reliable partner to other nations and strengthen its domestic research programs.
An order by President Biden places new rules on developers of “dual use” AI models, proposes visa reforms to attract talent in AI and other critical technologies, and directs agencies to expand research on AI applications.

Sign up for FYI This Week, our weekly digest of science policy news.

By signing up you agree to allow AIP to send you email newsletters. You further agree to our privacy policy and terms of service.