FYI: Science Policy News from AIP
THIS WEEK
What’s Ahead
house-appropriations-chair-kay-granger-2023.jpg
House Appropriations Committee Chair Kay Granger (R-TX). (House Appropriations Committee)

DOE and DOD Spending Proposals Advancing in House

The House Appropriations Committee is meeting on Thursday to debate its draft spending bills for the Department of Energy and Department of Defense, which Republicans released last week along with their spending allocations for the panel’s 12 subcommittees. Committee Chair Kay Granger (R-TX) has decided to advance bills that significantly undershoot the spending cap just approved through the deal to raise the debt ceiling, though the cuts would be offset in some cases by redirecting funds previously appropriated through special legislation such as the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act. The Senate Appropriations Committee is setting subcommittee allocations on Thursday that will likely meet the spending levels allowed by the debt ceiling deal.
House Republicans will release detailed spending proposals in conjunction with this week’s meetings. Their overarching proposals include level funding for the DOE Office of Science and Office of Nuclear Energy and a 12% cut for the base budget of the Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy. Their bill would also redirect $3.6 billion previously appropriated through the infrastructure act toward advanced nuclear reactor development initiatives and rescind more than $5 billion in energy efficiency funds from the Inflation Reduction Act. Republicans previewed additional proposals via a fact sheet last week, including a rejection of the Biden administration’s push to create a new national lab located at a minority-serving institution and a prohibition on DOE spending funds to implement its Equity Action Plan or the administration’s Justice40 initiative. Democrats identified this restriction on diversity initiatives as among their main reasons for opposing the legislation.
FY24-DOE-house-approps.png
Biden administration and House budget proposals for Department of Energy offices for fiscal year 2024. See details in FYI’s (AIP)

Committee Work on Annual Defense Bill Wrapping Up

The Senate Armed Services Committee is holding subcommittee meetings starting Tuesday to advance this year’s National Defense Authorization Act and the full committee will take up the bill later this week. Most of these meetings will be closed to the public and draft legislation will only be released after they have all concluded. The House Armed Services Committee is starting its own full committee meeting to amend the NDAA on Wednesday, which will be public. Committee Chair Mike Rogers (R-AL) has already released his draft of the bill, complementing provisions that advanced through subcommittee last week. House proposals introduced so far include measures intended to accelerate the transition of defense technology into use and to expand the military’s use of commercial technologies. One of these would involve revising the title and responsibilities of the under secretary of defense for research and engineering and another would create a pilot program to advance “near-term” quantum computing applications. A few proposals address research security, including one that would authorize DOD to contract with “consortia” to assist universities in implementing research security policies and vetting visiting scholars.

Schumer to Announce AI Legislation, Science Committee Hears from AI Experts

Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) is revealing his legislative framework for regulating artificial intelligence on Wednesday at the Center for Strategic and International Studies. Schumer previewed the framework in April and has begun organizing a series of briefings for senators on AI as Congress scrambles to better understand the technology. The House Science Committee is holding its first AI-focused hearing this year on Thursday, inviting testimony from five AI experts currently working outside of government. The committee played a lead role in developing the National AI Initiative Act of 2020, which outlined R&D policies for non-defense programs but did not regulate the technology.

Budget Panel Probing Oil and Insurance Companies’ Handling of Climate Risk

The Senate Budget Committee is holding a hearing on Wednesday titled, “Investigating Fossil Fuel Dark Money’s Systemic Threats to Climate and the Federal Budget.” One of the witnesses is Harvard University historian Naomi Oreskes, who has researched how fossil fuel companies have sowed doubt about climate science even though they have long been aware of the climate change risks posed by carbon emissions. Also testifying are ethics law professor Richard Painter, filmmaker Christine Arena, climate policy scholar Roger Pielke Jr., and physicist Steven Koonin, who has argued that the risks of climate change are overstated. Committee Chair Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI) has focused the panel on climate risks since taking on the role this year and last week launched an investigation into insurance companies continuing to underwrite fossil fuel production projects even as they limit homeowner insurance in some regions of the U.S. due to the increasing risk of catastrophic natural disasters. (Update: Koonin was on the initial list of witnesses but later replaced with a different witness.)

Academies Kicking Off Ocean Sciences Decadal, NIST Reactor Assessment

The National Academies is kicking off a decadal survey for the National Science Foundation’s Division of Ocean Sciences this week. The survey committee is tasked with recommending research and infrastructure priorities that will “advance understanding of the ocean’s role in the Earth system and the sustainable blue economy” and help the division quickly respond to emerging opportunities over the 2025-to-2035 time frame. The survey will also include an interim report focused on infrastructure for scientific ocean drilling, given NSF’s recent withdrawal from the international drilling ship JOIDES Resolution. The committee is co-chaired by Oregon State University ocean engineer Tuba Özkan-Haller and Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution Dean Emeritus Jim Yoder. Separately this week, the National Academies is launching a routine assessment of the National Institute of Standards and Technology’s Center for Neutron Research, which recently received approval to resume operations after a two-year shutdown.

NASA to Open Earth Information Center

NASA is holding a ribbon-cutting ceremony on Wednesday for its new Earth Information Center, an exhibit opening to the public on June 26 at the agency’s headquarters in Washington, DC. NASA Administrator Bill Nelson, Chief Scientist Kate Calvin, and Earth Science Division Director Karen St. Germain will speak at the event. The exhibit is the physical component of a resource also housed online that aims to inform decisions on climate change mitigation and adaptation. While the underlying datasets are already publicly available, the center will focus on accessibility and visualization, with an initial emphasis on building prototype capabilities for greenhouse gas monitoring. Proposed in NASA’s fiscal year 2023 budget request, the center is a collaborative effort with the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, U.S. Geological Survey, U.S. Department of Agriculture, U.S. Agency for International Development, Federal Emergency Management Agency, and Environmental Protection Agency.
In Case You Missed It
nsf-engine-semifinalists.png
Still image from an (NSF)

NSF Reveals Semifinalists for Regional ‘Engines’

The National Science Foundation announced 34 semifinalists on June 14 in the first competition of its Regional Innovation Engines program, which aims to foster public-private collaborations in key technology and societal challenge areas concentrated in specific geographic regions. Most of the semifinalist proposals relate to advanced manufacturing, sustainability and clean energy, or health and bioscience. There is also one semifinalist in each of the areas of quantum and microelectronics research. From the semifinalists, the agency expects to select five proposals to receive “Engine” grants of up to $160 million over 10 years. The remaining semifinalists will be eligible for smaller grants of $1 million over two years to further develop their proposals. The program awarded 44 of such grants this spring to applicants who did not compete for the larger grants.

House Republicans Advance R&D Tax Credit Reform

The House Ways and Means Committee advanced legislation last week called the Build It in America Act that would reverse a provision in the 2017 tax overhaul law that weakened the R&D tax credit by requiring companies to amortize qualified research expenses rather than immediately deducting them. The change went into effect in 2022, and the committee’s bill would push that date back to 2026 and allow companies to retroactively deduct research expenses for 2022. The committee approved the bill on a party-line vote, with all Republicans voting in favor. Committee Ranking Member Richard Neal (D-MA) indicated he is open to reverting to the pre-2017 policy but sought to narrow its scope through an amendment that would retain the amortization requirement for R&D conducted in China. He also argued against applying the extension retroactively, asserting that it would “reward companies for the research and development they conducted last year that they needed no incentive to undertake.” The bill would also roll back clean-energy tax credits established by the Inflation Reduction Act, a move that Democrats strongly oppose and is likely to prevent the bill from gaining traction in the Senate.

Fusion Leaders Receive Warm Reception From Science Committee

Members of the House Science Committee reiterated their interest in advancing fusion energy during a hearing last week, at which witnesses urged support for wide-ranging public and private efforts. Fusion Industry Association CEO Andrew Holland noted his organization has 37 member companies as well as 72 affiliate members with a stake in fusion power and that cumulative investment has more than doubled to nearly $6 billion since the committee’s last hearing on the subject in late 2021. Kathy McCarthy, who directs U.S. participation in the international ITER fusion facility, briefly discussed the serious engineering problems ITER is facing as well as the dismissal of senior project leaders by its new director-general, which she referred to as “organizational adjustments.” However, committee members did not probe the subject and Committee Chair Frank Lucas (R-OK) instead used his first question to invite McCarthy to defend ITER’s relevance amid burgeoning private-sector work in fusion. She replied that, even if smaller projects achieve major fusion milestones first, ITER will still be an important research facility for exploring various fusion concepts that will help foster a full-fledged fusion industry.

Risks of Nuclear War and Terrorism Explored by Academies Study

Last week, the National Academies released a study assessing the status of risk analysis surrounding war and terrorism involving nuclear weapons. It stresses that, because there is little direct evidence to draw on, the subject is pervaded by “great uncertainties” that are driven by the variety of scenarios involved as well as the assumptions and biases underlying the different methods and modes of expertise that risk analyses draw on. The study responds to a provision in the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2020 and was co-chaired by Stanford University professor Marie-Elisabeth Paté-Cornell and William Ostendorff, a retired nuclear submarine officer and former official at the National Nuclear Security Administration and Nuclear Regulatory Commission. A related study on environmental effects of nuclear war other than fallout is holding its first information-gathering session this week.
Events This Week
All times are Eastern Daylight Time, unless otherwise noted. Listings do not imply endorsement.

Monday, June 19

Juneteenth Holiday

Tuesday, June 20

National Academies: “Climate Intervention in an Earth Systems Science Framework”
(continues through Thursday)
Senate: Subcommittee meetings to advance the FY24 National Defense Authorization Act
(continues Wednesday)
Armed Services Committee
Commerce Department: National AI Advisory Committee meeting
2:00 - 3:00 pm

Wednesday, June 21

NASA: Planetary Science Advisory Committee meeting
(continues through Friday)
National Academies: “Assessment of the NIST Center for Neutron Research”
(continues through Friday)
Senate: Closed full committee meeting to advance the FY24 National Defense Authorization Act
(continues through Friday)
Armed Services Committee
DOD: Defense Science Board meeting
(continues Thursday)
House: “Oversight of the FCC”
10:30 am, Energy and Commerce Committee

Thursday, June 22

NOAA: 2023 Space Weather Enterprise Forum
8:30 am - 4:45 pm
Senate: Hearing on FCC nominees
10:00 am, Commerce, Science, and Transportation Committee
Commerce Department: National AI Advisory Committee meeting
2:00 - 3:00 pm
National Academies: “Climate Conversations: Artificial Intelligence”
3:30 - 4:45 pm

Friday, June 23

EPA: Science Advisory Board meeting
12:00 - 5:00 pm

Monday, June 26

Federal Lab Consortium: “Lab Showcase: Here is NIST!”
3:15 - 4:15 pm
Know of an upcoming science policy event either inside or outside the Beltway? Email us at fyi@aip.org.
Opportunities

National Academies Hiring Director for Atmospheric Sciences, Climate, and Polar Research

The National Academies is hiring a director to oversee its Polar Research Board and its Board on Atmospheric Sciences and Climate. Candidates should have a strong technical background in related sciences as well as experience growing relationships with federal, state, and private sponsors. They must also have ten years of professional experience, including five in a supervisory capacity.

Schmidt Futures Hiring Science Philanthropy Associate

Schmidt Futures, a philanthropic initiative founded by former Google CEO Eric Schmidt, is hiring a science associate to help develop and evaluate its portfolio of science philanthropy. Candidates should have a graduate degree in a STEM field and experience in research, analysis, consulting, or management.

DOE Seeking Input on Biological and Environmental Data Management

The Department of Energy’s Office of Science is seeking input on areas of biological and environmental research that could benefit from improved data accessibility and integration. Feedback will inform a forthcoming advisory committee report that will recommend a “next generation data management and analysis” strategy for the office’s Biological and Environmental Research program. Comments are due Oct. 31.
Know of an opportunity for scientists to engage in science policy? Email us at fyi@aip.org.
Around the Web
News and views currently in circulation. Links do not imply endorsement.

White House

Congress

Washington Post: Inflation Reduction Act foes race to repeal climate, drug pricing programs
Sen. John Cornyn (R-TX): Counter China in defense bill, not Schumer’s ‘China Bill 2.0’
House China Select Committee: Alfred University closes Confucius Institute as a result of committee investigation
House China Select Committee: Republicans seek answers from DOJ on Chinese IP theft
Washington Post: Lawmakers propose ‘blue-ribbon’ AI commission
Washington Post: Congress is racing to regulate AI. Silicon Valley is eager to teach them how
House Science Committee: Committee advances DOE research partnerships bills and FAA R&D bill
House Science Committee: Committee leaders send letter to Commerce Department inspector general regarding the disclosure of the identity of a whistleblower
Senate Energy Committee: Ranking Member Barrasso (R-WY) calls for investigation of Energy Secretary Granholm’s financial holdings
American Astronomical Society: A letter to congressional appropriations leadership
Wired: UFO whistleblower claims may gain traction on Capitol Hill

Science, Society, and the Economy

Education and Workforce

Research Management

Labs and Facilities

Computing and Communications

Argonne National Lab: Visionary report unveils ambitious roadmap to harness the power of AI in scientific discovery
GAO: S&T spotlight on generative AI
AP: How Europe is leading the world in the push to regulate AI
Science|Business: European Parliament agrees research should have exemptions in draft artificial intelligence law
Treasury Department: Treasury Department bolsters semiconductor supply chain confidence with key CHIPS investment tax credit guidance
HPCwire: Texas throws stake in race to get funds from US CHIPS Act
Bloomberg: Germany, Intel agree on €10 billion subsidy package for chip plant
Financial Times: Intel to spend $25 billion on Israel chip plant upgrade, says Netanyahu
Politico: Build better ties instead of only asking for microchips, Taiwan tells Europe
Wall Street Journal: US to allow South Korean, Taiwan chip makers to keep operations in China
Wall Street Journal: Watering down China chip restrictions sometimes makes sense (perspective by Jacky Wong)
Deutsche Welle: German university entangled in China’s quantum military strategy
Physics World: UK announces £45 million boost for quantum technology research
New York Times: Quantum computing advance begins new era, IBM says

Space

Weather, Climate, and Environment

British Antarctic Survey: Polar science for a sustainable planet: BAS launches new 10-year science strategy
NSF: US Antarctic Program facing severe shortage of logistics resources, upcoming research season will be significantly curtailed
Federation of American Scientists: Save lives by making smoke tracking a core part of wildland fire management (perspective by Alistair Hayden)
National Academies: New report recommends EPA develop framework for evaluating new approach methods for toxicity testing
E&E News: Watchdog probes EPA air chief’s ethics lapse
Bloomberg: Carbon air-capture technology is struggling for maturity
Wall Street Journal: Companies are shelling out big dollars to get rights to subsurface holes where they hope to store carbon dioxide
National Academies: Carbon dioxide utilization markets and infrastructure: Status and opportunities (report)
Vox: NASA’s newest X-plane wants to save the planet

Energy

E&E News: Granholm details views on climate law and DOE staffing
Reuters: DOE and other agencies hit in global hacking spree
DOE: DOE announces $192 million to advance battery recycling technology
Idaho National Lab: Finally, an industrial-scale facility for testing new, clean hydrogen technologies
E&E News: Renewable group shifts position, shakes up clean hydrogen debate
New York Times: Why the US pays billions to Russia’s nuclear agency
Exchange Monitor: NRC gives Centrus green light for high assay low-enriched uranium demo
Nuclear Energy Institute: Is the Nuclear Regulatory Commission ready to meet the moment?
Physics Today: European Union nations grapple with nuclear waste storage
South China Morning Post: China gives green light to nuclear reactor that burns thorium
Ars Technica: Congress shows interest in space-based solar power

Defense

Biomedical

International Affairs

This message is sent to you because your email address is on our subscribers list. To manage your AIP preferences and subscriptions, please click here. Or to automatically unsubscribe from all AIP emails, click here.

AIP, 1 Physics Ellipse, MD 20740-3841
301.209.3100 - newsletters@aipcomm.org

As a 501(c)(3) non-profit, AIP is a federation that advances the success of our Member Societies and an institute that engages in research and analysis to empower positive change in the physical sciences. The mission of AIP (American Institute of Physics) is to advance, promote, and serve the physical sciences for the benefit of humanity.

© 2024. American Institute of Physics