FYI: Science Policy News from AIP
THIS WEEK
What’s Ahead
msr-sample-brightness-adjusted400x800.jpg
A sample collected from the surface of Mars by the Perseverance rover is awaiting possible retrieval by a mission that is now in danger of being canceled. (NASA / JPL-Caltech / MSSS)

Constrained Budget Proposals Put Mars Sample Return in Peril

The outlook for science agency budgets will come into clearer focus this week as congressional appropriators continue to advance their fiscal year 2024 spending bills. Last week, House and Senate appropriators each released bills that would cut NASA’s Science Mission Directorate by more than 5%, with the Senate proposing to slash funding for the Mars Sample Return mission from $822 million to $300 million and calling for NASA to cancel the mission if its total estimated cost cannot be brought under $5.3 billion, a limit virtually certain to be exceeded. Details of the House proposal will not be released until after it is considered by the full Appropriations Committee, potentially later this week, but meeting the $950 million requested for MSR would be impossible under the proposal’s topline for the Science Mission Directorate without imposing severe cuts across other activities.
Other science agencies are also facing tighter budgets. The National Science Foundation would receive a budget cut of 2% under the House proposal and 4% under the Senate proposal. The House also aims to cut the U.S. Geological Survey by 10%, though the Senate proposal for that agency is still pending. Senate appropriators are scheduled to consider their proposal for the Department of Energy on Thursday. House appropriators have already advanced a DOE proposal that includes level funding for the Office of Science, a 13% cut for the Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, and an 8% increase for the National Nuclear Security Administration. Keep up to date on budget proposals across agencies with FYI’s Federal Science Budget Tracker.

Senate Takes Up NDAA as Research Restrictions Advance in House

The Senate will take up its draft of the National Defense Authorization Act on the floor this week, following close behind the House, which passed its version of the bill last week. During the House floor debate, several provisions seeking to constrict research ties with China were added to the bill on voice votes, including ones that would:
  • Prohibit all federal agencies from directly or indirectly funding research conducted by any “agent or instrumentality” of the Chinese government or the Chinese Communist Party, or by “any entity owned by or controlled by the People’s Republic of China.”
  • Generally prohibit the Department of Defense from funding any institution of higher education that collaborates in fundamental research with an “entity of concern” or several categories of research institutions associated with the Chinese military.
  • Generally prohibit DOD from providing R&D funding to any “entity that maintains a contract” with an academic institution in China, Russia, or other countries to be specifically identified.
  • Generally prohibit DOD from funding any cooperative biomedical research program with the Chinese government or “China-affiliated organizations.”
The vote on the House bill was split 219-210, mainly along party lines, with Democrats objecting to a series of Republican floor amendments restricting DOD support for diversity and inclusion initiatives and for service members seeking abortions and gender-affirming medical care. Any provision in either version of the bill could be dropped or altered when House and Senate negotiators eventually meet to finalize the legislation.

Package of Nuclear Technology Bills up for Discussion

The House Energy and Commerce Committee is holding a hearing on Tuesday to consider a slate of bills aimed at streamlining the nuclear licensing process and promoting the competitiveness of the U.S. nuclear energy industry. These include ones that would reduce application fees for advanced nuclear reactor licenses, allow DOE to award prizes to cover the costs of licensing “certain first-of-a-kind” reactors, and establish regulatory requirements for microreactors. The Nuclear Fuel Security Act, which has also been introduced in the Senate, would direct DOE to accelerate efforts to develop a domestic source of high-assay, low-enriched uranium (HALEU) for use in advanced reactors. However, the bill does not include a funding target, whereas the Senate version proposes that Congress immediately provide $3.5 billion to improve uranium availability, including $1 billion for HALEU.
In Case You Missed It
NOAA Fire Clouds800x500.jpg
Pyrocumulonimbus clouds formed by fires in Canada in May 2023, imaged by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration’s GOES-18 satellite. (NOAA)

Science Committee Preparing Wildfire Legislation

The House Science Committee held a hearing last Wednesday to explore opportunities for improving the prediction of weather conditions that increase the risk of extreme wildfires and to inform prospective legislation addressing wildfire preparedness. Witnesses testified on regulatory limitations the commercial sector faces in developing remote sensing technologies, as well as on the importance of fire risk mitigation and communication. Earlier this year, committee member Rep. Mike Garcia (R-CA) introduced the Fire Information and Reaction Enhancement (FIRE) Act, which would direct the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration to build one or more fire-weather testbeds for improving wildfire detection and forecasting, with a target budget of $15 million. After last week’s hearing, Committee Ranking Member Zoe Lofgren (D-CA) reintroduced the Wildland Fire Risk Reduction Program Act, which Democrats previously advanced in 2021 without Republican support. The legislation would establish an interagency program focused on wildfire prediction and mitigation with an initial cross-agency budget target of about $400 million.

Spectrum Management Bills Gaining Steam in House

The House Energy and Commerce Committee advanced two spectrum management policy bills through subcommittee last week, including the first bill to reauthorize the National Telecommunications and Information Administration in three decades. The bill would elevate NTIA’s standing within the Department of Commerce, codify its Office of Spectrum Management and Spectrum Management Advisory Committee, and provide guidance for its role of communicating the interests of federal spectrum users to the Federal Communications Commission. The committee also advanced the Spectrum Relocation Enhancement Act, which would encourage federal agencies to terminate or share their existing spectrum allocations by allowing them to access a portion of the revenue from FCC auctions of bands relinquished for commercial use. It would also permit auction revenues to support R&D on spectrum reallocation. Earlier this year, the committee approved the Spectrum Coordination Act, which would require NTIA to publicly detail any concerns federal agencies have over pending spectrum auctions. The FCC’s legal authority to auction spectrum bands lapsed in March and auctions cannot resume until Congress passes legislation to renew it.

NSF Aims to Improve Rigor of Research Security Policy With New Program

The National Science Foundation released new details last week on its planned “Research on Research Security Program,” which seeks to bring greater rigor to policies aimed at preventing foreign actors from misappropriating U.S.-funded research. The program will fund academic research focused on identifying the scale of research security threats and assessing associated risk mitigation methods across areas such as cybersecurity, foreign travel security, and export control training. The program’s scope is informed by a recent JASON advisory panel report that NSF commissioned and will be further shaped by an upcoming workshop. NSF is holding a webinar on July 26 to elaborate on the program’s goals and preview the workshop. The agency first announced plans to create the program in its fiscal year 2024 budget request.

NSF Awards $162 Million for Materials Research Centers

The National Science Foundation announced awards for nine Materials Research Science and Engineering Centers last month, each funded at $18 million over six years. Seven of the universities in this latest cohort previously operated MRSECs and two are new hosts: The University of Michigan will operate a center focused on nanoscale structures for quantum computing and self-healing polymers, and the University of Tennessee will operate a center focused on applying artificial intelligence to research in quantum materials and developing materials suited for use in nuclear fusion reactors and hypersonic defense systems. NSF holds competitions for MRSECs on a staggered six-year cycle and, with the latest awards, is supporting a total of 20 centers.
Events This Week
All times are Eastern Daylight Time, unless otherwise noted. Listings do not imply endorsement.

Monday, July 17

Tuesday, July 18

National Academies: Panel on Assessment of Electromagnetic Spectrum Sciences meeting
(continues through Thursday)
Aspen Institute: Aspen Security Forum
(continues through Friday)
NASA: Exploration Science Forum 2023
(continues through Thursday)

Wednesday, July 19

Mission Innovation: 8th Mission Innovation meeting
(continues through Saturday)
DOD: Defense Science Board meeting
(continues Thursday)
House: Members’ Day Hearing
2:00 pm, Science Committee
Senate: Hearing on water management legislation
2:30 pm, Energy and Natural Resources Committee
House: Meeting to advance small business innovation legislation
3:00 pm, Small Business Committee
Brookings Institution: “The Geopolitics of Generative AI”
3:00 - 4:00 pm

Thursday, July 20

House: “The Biden Administration’s PRC Strategy”
8:00 am, Select Committee on China
DOD: U.S. Army Science Board meeting
8:15 am - 1:45 pm
Senate: “NOAA Budget Oversight”
9:30 am, Commerce, Science, and Transportation Committee
Senate: “America’s Supply Chain Security: Understanding and Mitigating Threats”
10:00 am, Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee
Senate: Meeting to advance the Pandemic and All-Hazards Preparedness and Response Act
10:30 am, Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions Committee

Friday, July 21

Monday, July 24

NDIA: 2023 CBRN Defense Conference
(continues through Wednesday)
Know of an upcoming science policy event either inside or outside the Beltway? Email us at fyi@aip.org.
Opportunities

DOD Hiring Director for Advanced Materials

The Department of Defense is hiring a director for advanced materials, who will oversee related research and engineering activities across the department. Applicants must have a degree in engineering or a physical sciences field, broad knowledge of advanced materials disciplines, and demonstrated knowledge of defense R&D, budget, and acquisition processes. Applications are due July 31.

Space Studies Board Hiring Interns

The National Academies is seeking interns for the Space Studies Board, who will be assigned a variety of clerical and research duties. Applicants must be currently enrolled in an undergraduate or graduate degree program.

OSTP Seeking Input on National Ocean Economy Strategy

The White House Office of Science and Technology Policy is seeking input to inform a National Strategy for a Sustainable Ocean Economy. The strategy is being developed by an interagency committee and will cover a variety of subject areas, such as ocean science and technology, climate change, and ocean energy and resources. Comments are due Aug. 28.
Know of an opportunity for scientists to engage in science policy? Email us at fyi@aip.org.
Around the Web
News and views currently in circulation. Links do not imply endorsement.

White House

Congress

Science, Society, and the Economy

The Conversation: Science activism is surging, marking a culture shift among scientists (perspective by Scott Frickel and Fernando Tormos-Aponte)
New York Times: ‘Oppenheimer’ shows science at the mercy of politics (perspective by Kai Bird)
New York Times: Everett Mendelsohn, who linked science and society, dies at 91
NBER: Moonshot: Public R&D and growth (paper by Shawn Kantor and Alexander Whalley)
Scranton Times-Tribune: Public investments help power advancements (perspective by Rep. Matt Cartwright (D-PA) and Sethuraman Panchanathan)
Wall Street Journal: Private explorers like the ones who perished on the Titan submersible have a crucial role to play in expanding the frontiers of knowledge (perspective by Richard Garriott de Cayeux)
New York Times: Science museums take stock of 1.1 billion objects from around the world

Education and Workforce

Research Management

Labs and Facilities

Computing and Communications

Bloomberg: Chip leaders head to Washington to lobby for China rules relief
ITIF: Export controls shrink the global markets US semiconductors need to survive (perspective by Robert Atkinson)
South China Morning Post: Intel CEO wraps up low-key China trip as US chip giant taps hot Chinese demand for semiconductors
New York Times: ‘An act of war’: Inside America’s silicon blockade against China
Penn State University: Workshop fosters partnerships to position US as leader in semiconductors
Science: Introduction to special issue on AI
Science: AI safety on whose terms? (perspective by Seth Lazar and Alondra Nelson)
Federation of American Scientists: Six policy ideas for the national AI strategy
New York Times: Can AI invent?
Nature: How to introduce quantum computers without slowing economic growth (perspective by Chander Velu and Fathiro Putra)

Space

Weather, Climate, and Environment

Energy

Defense

Biomedical

Nature: Public-health specialist Mandy Cohen faces a daunting to-do list as she takes lead of the CDC
House Energy and Commerce Committee: Republicans argue 14 NIH officials, including Dr. Fauci, held unlawful positions and exercised authority that they didn’t have
House Energy and Commerce Committee: Democrats blasts House Republicans’ unfounded assertions that NIH officials were incorrectly reappointed
Washington Post: As pandemic raged, global south lacked vaccines. Never again, researchers vow
Institute for Progress: How NSF moved faster than NIH during COVID-19 (perspective by Maxwell Tabarrok)
National Academies: Third International Summit on Human Genome Editing: Expanding capabilities, participation, and access (report)
Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists: Nuclear safety staffing in the US: A crisis with no easy fix (perspective by David Gillum)
Reuters: Johnson & Johnson sues researchers who linked talc to cancer

International Affairs

ScienceInsider: India aims to invigorate science with hefty new funding agency
Research Professional: UK R&D sector voices concern over planned visa fee hike
Times Higher Education: China is ‘stealing UK academic research’ in ‘plain sight’ and suppressing political dissent on campus, says UK intelligence committee
DESY: Meetings in Berlin and Beijing on research cooperation with China
Research Professional: Robbert Dijkgraaf departs as Dutch science minister with several research and education initiatives incomplete
ScienceInsider: Science partnerships between Portugal and top US universities under threat
Science|Business: European Commission announces plan to improve working conditions for young researchers
Science|Business: EU member states want to cut proposed €400 million increase in the 2024 research budget
NBER: War and science in Ukraine (paper by Ina Ganguli and Fabian Waldinger)

This message is sent to you because your email address is on our subscribers list. To manage your AIP preferences and subscriptions, please click here. Or to automatically unsubscribe from all AIP emails, click here.

AIP, 1 Physics Ellipse, MD 20740-3841
301.209.3100 - newsletters@aipcomm.org

As a 501(c)(3) non-profit, AIP is a federation that advances the success of our Member Societies and an institute that engages in research and analysis to empower positive change in the physical sciences. The mission of AIP (American Institute of Physics) is to advance, promote, and serve the physical sciences for the benefit of humanity.

© 2024. American Institute of Physics